The Intersection of Financial Institutions and Technology Leaders

From Leaky Bucket to Leading Lender

January 13, 2025

By Alex McLeod, Jay Long

Small business lending represents a $1 trillion annual opportunity for banks — provided they have the right technology and processes to compete. A persistent obstacle for many lenders is the leaky bucket problem: fragmented workflows, manual processes and broken handoffs. Despite heavy automation investments to patch these gaps, banks often fail to capture the most valuable resource: data. 

In today’s banking landscape, powered by artificial intelligence, the difference between market leaders and laggards goes beyond sophisticated technology — it’s about capturing the necessary data to generate actionable insights. As fintech challengers and national banks leverage data and AI to capture small business lending market share, community and regional institutions must adapt or risk being held back by legacy processes, blind spots in data collection and analysis, and missed opportunities for AI-driven growth.

The small business loan application process resembles a leaky bucket. Every manual step, fragmented system and communication gap creates another opportunity for valuable prospects to slip away. Small businesses seek quick, straightforward and tailored financing, but often encounter rigid documentation requirements, repetitive data entry and inflexible product offerings. This causes application abandonments, biased credit decisions and an increasingly tough battle to maintain an advantage in relationship banking.

These friction points fundamentally distort a bank’s market view. Most risk models rely on a narrow slice of prescreened applications, creating hidden biases that skew both risk assessment and market analysis. Few lenders can measure their credit box’s real-time impact on profitability or analyze how eligibility criteria affects their bottom line. Even automated scoring for small-dollar loans often depends on generic credit scores that miss crucial indicators of business health and customer lifetime value. Consequently, many lenders use the wrong tools and insights to make critical business decisions.

Each leak represents a double loss: the immediate revenue from creditworthy businesses abandoning the process, along with the vital data that could strengthen risk models, boost conversion rates and drive product innovation. Without understanding where and why qualified applicants drop out, banks can’t execute strategic growth plans.

While some banks struggle with small business data, market leaders are deploying intelligent systems to capture creditworthy businesses. Small businesses, particularly those seeking smaller loans, represent prime opportunities for digital-forward banks to reduce acquisition costs and build stronger relationships. As these firms expand, they can generate multiple revenue streams through cross-selling and deposits, with stronger loyalty to their institution than rate-shopping customers.

The key to capturing this market is loan intelligence systems (LIS), a new category of AI-powered intake technology that complements loan origination systems by addressing leaks and optimizing data capture. Loan intelligence systems match businesses to appropriate products, from rapid-scored loans to larger relationship-driven products, optimizing both customer experience and operational efficiency. Most importantly, they provide real-time, validated insights that help bankers build lasting relationships and maximize customer lifetime value. 

This holistic approach enables lenders to:

• Transform scattered interactions into actionable intelligence by identifying bottlenecks and optimizing credit boxes based on actual customer behavior.
• Build sophisticated, bank-specific AI models that align with risk profiles and balance sheet strategies while maximizing customer lifetime value.
• Develop targeted products informed by deep customer insights, allowing for better segmentation and market penetration.
• Route applicants to risk-adjusted, tailored product types based on business needs.

Small business lending today depends on robust data sets to power intelligent decisions. As AI-powered tools transform lending, data quality and completeness are critical differentiators. While fintech disruptors and large banks set new standards with AI-driven speed and service, many institutions still face significant blind spots in their lending operations. Forward-thinking banks must assess their current position by asking:

• Do we have real-time visibility into the top of the small business lending funnel?
• Do current systems validate applicant data and track drop-off points?
• Can existing systems predict and track customer lifetime value from the first interaction?
• Are our credit risk assessments informed by comprehensive applicant data?
• How does our institution leverage real-time analytics to improve key margins?

Without comprehensive, real-time data, even the most sophisticated AI tools fail to deliver a lasting competitive advantage. The winners will be those institutions that leverage LIS to build the rich data foundation for risk-adjusted growth. When lenders can clearly see their entire lending funnel, they become trusted partners to long-term customers, instead of transaction lenders for rate shoppers.

An LIS moves beyond operational fixes to provide comprehensive data insights that power effective AI and risk decisions in modern small business lending. In small business lending, tomorrow’s leaders are building their data foundation today.

Alex McLeod is the Co-Founder and CEO of Parlay Finance, the first-of-its-kind small business loan intelligence system that helps lenders get more small businesses approved for SBA 7(A) and small-dollar loans.

Jay Long is the Co-Founder and COO of Parlay Finance. Throughout his career, he has focused on building and helping teams tackle complex challenges through lean product development cycles using his experiences as an author, soldier, design thinker, and startup adviser.